Genetic Report
Description of the performed Search and the results
In the last fifteen years varied attempts have been completed, to work
of different international equips, to recover material genetic from
human rests mummified deriving from situated archaeological of Egypt.
Nevertheless, while the first publications, exits in the scientific
literature, pointed out that, at least in some mummies, they were indeed
present residual of the original DNA, following results have not
confirmed, or they have confirmed partially only these observations.
It is necessary to specify, on the subject, that the search
archeomolecular has made particularly difficult from varied factors. For
example, the residual DNA, if it foresees, it is very rare however and
strongly damaged. Besides the possibility exists always (in I dig it
archaeological as in the laboratory) that the champion comes to contact
with modern human DNA, with the result to produce unreliable data. At
the present moment, therefore, there is, also in specialist field, a
state of notable uncertainty on the validity of the analysis of the DNA
in the sector of the Egyptology. E' instead recognized the value of this
test in the study of the mummies and of the human skeletal rests
and deriving animals from cold climates.
For this motive we have conducted some studies finalized to verify, in
the most rigorous way, the presence, or less, of original DNA in a group
of deriving finds from excavations or from collections egyptologic. To
such elegant, for every find the parameters shown has been determined.
Is of diagenesi of the organic material: is determined
through the isolation of the collagene from bony champions or of
desiccated soft fabric which follows the examination of the degree of
racemizzazione of the sour aspartico (D/LAsp); a relationship inferior
D/LAsp to 0.8 is considered compatible with the maintenance of the DNA,
while a value superior D/LAsp to 0.8-1.0 index of degradation of the
material is considered.
Presence and state of maintenance of the DNA mitocondriale:
is determined through the extraction of the total nucleic acids from the
champion and the enzymatic amplification of the DNA through PCR, using
specific systems for the regions ipervariabili (HVR) of the molecule;
every cell of mammal contains 1000-10.000 copies of DNA mitocondriale,
while it is containing two copies of the nuclear DNA only, the first one
results therefore more easily traceable of the second in the material
archeos - and paleoanthropologic.
Presence and state of maintenance of the bacterial DNA:
is
determined through the extraction of the total nucleic acids from the
champion and the enzymatic amplification of the DNA through PCR using
specific systems for the gene procariotico for the RNA ribosomale 16S
(rDNA 16S); the examination furnishes important information on the
composition of the microbial flora of a dead body (cadaverous flora),
therefore it can serve to understand the mechanisms (natural or
artificial) that have produced a phenomenon of mummification.
These tests have been applied to the examination of champions of soft
fabric and bony fabric isolated by the followings human rests:
1) mummy of Merneit, of epoch Saitic (VII-there sec. b.C.), necropolis
of Saqqara;
2) mummy of individual of deriving masculine sex from the necropolis of
Saqqara (Ptolemaic Epoch);
3) mummy of individual of deriving female sex from the necropolis of
Saqqara (Ptolemaic Epoch);
4) "mummy of Narni" (III sec. b.C.).
The examination of the degree of racemizzazione of the sour aspartico
(D/LAsp), performed on the different champions, has furnished
superior values to 0.2, coherent with the absolute age of the materials.
Such results are, in line of principle, incompatible with the
maintenance of the DNA. Correspondingly, all the attempts to amplify DNA
human mitocondriale or bacterial DNA have produced negative results.
Particularly the examination of some fragments of ribs withdrawn by the
mummy of Merneit has shown that the contact of the bony fabric with the
organic substances used in the process of imbalsamation, doesn't
increase the ability of the DNA to survive in the time.
I have been then you examine two heads mummified preserved near
the Museum of History of the Medicine of the university in Rome. In
passed the heads they belonged to the harvests of the Egyptian Face in
Turin; they had moved in Rome to the years ' 50.
The determination of the degree of racemizzazione of the sour aspartico,
performed on champions of muscle and bone, has furnished, for
both the finds, a series of values that they oscillate between 0.6-0.75.
Such relationship is, as says above, index of a good state of
maintenance of the organic macromolecoles and it results compatible with
the maintenance of the aboriginal genetic material. Nevertheless, an
absolute dating through radiocarbonio performed in the edited by last
years the Archaeological Superintendence for the Abruzzo (Chieti) it
establishes, for one of the two heads, a non anterior age to the XVIII
century AD we Have therefore to that to do with built " forgeries " to
art for the Europeans that visited Egypt in the last centuries. These "
forgeries " are very interesting however for the scientific search in
how much they can help to clarify the mechanisms responsible of the
degradation of the human and bacterial DNA in the Egyptian environment.
Currently we are performing some examinations of the DNA mitocondriale
finalized to typify the heads anthropologically.
In a parallel search we have submitted some racemizzazione of the sour
aspartico to the examination of the DNA and that 13 fragments of
paper-papyrus of different age (Byzantine, Arab, Greek-Roman,
faraonica). In this case the examination of the DNA has consisted in the
search of fragments of the DNA of the plant (Cyperus papyrus) with which
the paper has been manufactured. The results have confirmed how much
previously observed in the case of the human mummies and that is that
the DNA, in the warm environment of Egypt it is degraded completely in
an arc of brief time relatively, respectable in 600-700 years.
The most important conclusions of the study is that, for
how much it concerns the archaeological sites of Egypt, it is extremely
unlikely that can be isolated material genetic original from the ancient
mummies. This is worth relatively also for the mummies of slow age, as
the Ptolemaic mummies. The speed of degradation of the DNA is, of other
song, sufficiently low because this molecule can recover in the "
forgeries " beginning from the Renaissance.
Produced of the performed Search
The principal product of the search consists in a new method to verify
the state of maintenance of the DNA in the material archaeological
Egyptian. Such method is founded on the observation that the speed of
decadence of the DNA and that of racemizzazione of the sour aspartico
are very similar in the paper-papyrus and in the human rests and
animals.
The method set consists of two parts:
1) a protocol of extraction of the aminoacidis of the ancient
paper-papyrus and determination of the relationship between the
enantiomeris D and L of the sour aspartico through HPLC;
2)un method of amplification of fragments of residual DNA using couples
of oligonucleotidi from us planned.
Between the products of the search it is from to also include a method
to identify the false " mummies " quickly through the examination of the
relationship D-L aspartico in fragments of desiccated soft fabric and
bone.
The methods are described in details in the publications listed in the
special paragraph.